# Explain Why It Is Impossible To Derive An Analytical Formula For Valu

# Explain Why It Is Impossible To Derive An Analytical Formula For Valu

**Length:** 1758 words (5 double-spaced pages)

**Rating:** Excellent

#### Essay Preview

More ↓Puts.

Explain why it has proved impossible to derive an analytical formula for valuing

American Puts, and outline the main techniques that are used to produce

approximate valuations for such securities

Investing in stock options is a way used by investors to hedge against risk. It

is simply because all the investors could lose if the option is not exercised

before the expiration rate is just the option price (that is the premium) that

he or she has paid earlier. Call options give the investor the right to buy the

underlying stock at the exercise price, X; while the put options give the

investor the right to sell the underlying security at X. However only America

options can be exercised at any time during the life of the option if the holder

sees fit while European options can only be exercised at the expiration rate,

and this is the reason why American put options are normally valued higher than

European options. Nonetheless it has been proved by academics that it is

impossible to derive an analytical formula for valuing American put options and

the reason why will be discussed in this paper as well as some main suggested

techniques that are used to value them.

According to Hull, exercising an American put option on a non-dividend-paying

stock early if it is sufficiently deeply in the money can be an optimal practice.

For example, suppose that the strike price of an American option is $20 and the

stock price is virtually zero. By exercising early at this point of time, an

investor makes an immediate gain of $20. On the contrary, if the investor waits,

he might not be able to get as much as $20 gain since negative stock prices are

impossible. Therefore it implies that if the share price was zero, the put

would have reached its highest possible value so the investor should exercise

the option early at this point of time.

Additionally, in general, the early exerices of a put option becomes more

attractive as S, the stock price, decreases; as r, the risk-free interest rate,

increases; and as , the volatility, decreases. Since the value of a put is

always positive as the worst can happen to it is that it expires worthless so

this can be expressed as where X is the strike price Therefore for an American put

with price P, , must always hold since the investor can execute immediate

exercise any time prior to the expiry date. As shown in Figure 1,

### How to Cite this Page

**MLA Citation:**

"Explain Why It Is Impossible To Derive An Analytical Formula For Valu."

__123HelpMe.com__. 16 Feb 2019

<http://bashambrothersmusic.com/view.asp?id=65020>.

## Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »## Essay Democracy Is An Impossible System Of Governance

- ... The idea that the people are alleged to make sensible decisions in our everyday community where public authorities then act upon these decisions bears no relationship to how it really works, or could ever possibly work. We live in a world dominated by technological advancements and economic prosperity where people are too occupied with getting to their jobs on time or picking up their kids from school. Citizens nowadays cannot and do not live up to these expectations. When the people do have time, they tend to spend it figuring out their taxes and paying their bills.... [tags: Democracy, Elections, Voting, Election]

**Research Papers**

1532 words (4.4 pages)

## The Theory Of Knowledge Is Impossible Essay

- After admitting that he does not know what virtue is almost halfway through Plato’s Meno, Meno states a few premises involving the acquisition of knowledge, which coined the term Meno’s paradox. In this paradox Meno says that virtue or knowledge is impossible to learn because of it. Meno then questions Socrates on how they can find what virtue is if they can’t discover it which I believe Socrates resolves by stating the theory of recollection and how the theory of recollection shows one part of the premise false by conversing with the slave boy.... [tags: Plato, Virtue, Ethics, Justice]

**Research Papers**

1579 words (4.5 pages)

## The Impact of Attending Seminars to the Development of the Analytical Skill of Financial Management Students

- The study tackles about “The Impact of Attending Seminars to the Development of the Analytical Skill of the Financial Management Students”. The discussion started by introducing what is seminars and its main purpose. Seminars help a lot to spread and inform the people about new informations and ideas. It provides also opportunities to the attendees to meet and know formal persons in different industries. The importance of seminars could also enhance skills of the attendees specifically the analytical skill of a person.... [tags: finance, analytical skill, seminars]

**Free Essays**

1981 words (5.7 pages)

## An Analytical Reflection Essay

- ... This task gave me a chance to reflect on out of the ordinary behavior in group settings. With this in mind, I tried to write a narrative on the most complicated individual I had encountered. Hindsight being 20/20, I am happy with the choice I made. To emphasize, trying to dissect his behavior, helped me tap into my own. In short, the narrative was a godsend for yours truly. The interview was a continuance of the narrative. The basis of that interview was to talk to an individual who could identify with your difficulties.... [tags: Psychology, Person, Paper, Subject]

**Research Papers**

718 words (2.1 pages)

## Essay on Development Of Rhetorical And Analytical Skills

- Development of Rhetorical and Analytical Skills through Sports. In “Hidden Intellectualism” by Gerald Graff, the author speaks about how schools should use students’ interests to develop their rhetorical and analytical skills. He spends a majority of his essay on telling his own experience of being sport loving and relating it to his anti-intellectual youth. He explains that through his love for sports, he developed rhetoric and began to analyze like an intellectual. Once he finishes his own story, he calls the schools to action advising them to not only allow students to use their interest as writing topics, but instead to teach the students on how to implement those compelling interests an... [tags: Rhetoric, Critical thinking, Logos, Logic]

**Research Papers**

1360 words (3.9 pages)

## My Writing And Analytical Skills Essay

- Throughout this semester in English 102, I feel that my writing and analytical skills have improved. I have always had trouble in writing ever since I was young kid. In my essays I would have words misspelled or my sentences would not flow because I would leave words left out. This course has taught me to always revise my essay and read it out loud to check for mistakes. I have also really learned to analysis different things like advertisements, books, articles, and other things that were assigned throughout this course.... [tags: Writing, Essay, Better, Essays]

**Research Papers**

1354 words (3.9 pages)

## Essay on Pure Evil: Humanly Impossible

- Pure Evil: Humanly Impossible In confidently stating that no human being, under any circumstances, would choose evil over goodness, Socrates believed that we are our souls. If a person is identified by their soul, then all actions he or she willingly performs are done so after carefully examining ones soul. Unless you look into your psyche, where lies the conscious self, you are not reflectively thinking. Socrates believed such a thing since he felt it was against human nature to desire what is ultimately harmful or evil for the soul.... [tags: Papers]

**Free Essays**

704 words (2 pages)

## Analytical Essay

- The construction last year of a shopping mall in downtown Oak City was a mistake. Since the mall has opened, a number of local businesses have closed, and the downtown area suffers from an acute parking shortage. Arrests for crime and vagrancy have increased in nearby Oak City Park. Elm City should pay attention to the example of the Oak City Mall and deny the application to build a shopping mall in Elm City. Analyzing this argument brings up a lot of questions to whether this is a relevant argument or not.... [tags: Analytical Essays]

**Free Essays**

664 words (1.9 pages)

## Explain Essay example

- Explain Explain the importance of the Magic If and Given Circumstances to Stanislavski’s psycho technique. Refer to any practical examples that will help explain this. MR GROGAN H/W In this essay I will be explaining the work we have been doing recently during this term and the relevance to our study of Stanislavski’s psycho technique. I will be outlining how his ideas of the ‘Magic If’ and ‘Given Circumstances’ contribute to the importance of this technique. Stanislavski had several ideas about how to achieve a sense of inner and outer truth in terms of his character, one being the magic if.... [tags: Drama]

**Research Papers**

1302 words (3.7 pages)

## Explain Essay

- Explain Explain what is happening in each of the following poems and compare and contrast the different ways in which they deal with the theme of sorrow. The first poem ‘Remember’ by Christina Rossetti is a late romantic, early Victorian sonnet, which is about someone who has passed away. ‘The chimney sweeper’ by William Blake, is written in 1740’s and is about a young child chimney sweep and his plight. ‘Remember’ is written in the narrative voice so that it seems as if the person who passed away is speaking.... [tags: English Literature]

**Free Essays**

833 words (2.4 pages)

### Related Searches

Here provided that r > 0, exercising an American put immediately always seems to

be optimal when the stock price is sufficiently low which means that the value

of the option is X - S. The graph representing the value of the put therefore

merges into the put's intrinsic value, X - S, for a sufficiently small value of

S which is shown as point A in the graph. When volatility and time to

expiration increase, the value of the put moves in the direction indicated by

the arrows.

In other words, according to Cox and Rubinstein, there must always be some

critical value, S`(z), for every time instant z between time t and time T, at

which the investor will exercise the put option if that critical value, S(z),

falls to or below this value (this is when the investor thinks it is the optimal

decision to follow). More importantly, this critical value, S`(z) will depend

on the time left to expiry which therefore also implies that S`(z) is actually a

function of the time to expiry. This function is referred to, according to

Walker, as the Optimum Exercise Boundary (OEB).

However in order to be able to value an American put option, we need to solve

for the put valuation foundation and then optimum exercise boundary at the same

time. Yet up to now, no one has managed to produce an analytical solution to

this problem so we have to depend on numerical solutions and some techniques

which are considered to be good enough for all practical purposes. (Walker,

1996)

There are basically three main techniques in use for American put option

valuations, which are known as the Binomial Trees, Finite Difference Methods,

and the Analytical Approximations in Option Pricing. These three techniques

will be discussed in turns as follows.

Cox et al claim that a more realistic model for option valuation is one that

assumes stock price movements are composed of a large number of small binomial

movements, which is the so-called Binomial Trees (Hull, p343, 3rd Ed).

Binomial trees assume that in each short interval of time, , over the life of

the option a stock price either moves “up” from its initial value of S to , or

moves “down” to . In general, > 1 and < 1. The probability of an up movement

will be denoted by thus, the probability for a down movement is . The basic

model of this simple binomial tree is shown in Figure 2. Furthermore, the risk-

neutral valuation principle is also in use when using a binomial tree, which

states that any security dependent on a stock price can be valued on the

assumption that the world is risk neutral. Therefore the risk-free interest rate

is the expected return from all traded securities and future cash flows can be

valued by discounting their expected values at the risk-free interest rate. The

parameters p, u, and d must give correct values for the mean and variance of

stock price changes during a time interval of length .

By using the binomial tree, options are evaluated by starting at the end of the

tree (that is time T) and working backward. The value of the option is known at

time T. As a risk-neutral world is being assumed, the value at each node at time

T - can be calculated as the expected value at time T discounted at rate r for a

time period . Similarly the value at each node at time T - can be calculated as

the expected value at time T - discounted for a time period at rate r, and so on.

When we are dealing with American options, it is necessary to check at each

node to see if early exercise is optimal rather than holding the option for a

longer while. Therefore by working the binomial backward through all the nodes,

the value of the option at time zero is obtained.

For example, consider a five-month American put option on a non-dividend-paying

stock when the stock price is $50, the strike price is $50, the risk-free

interest rate is 10% per annum, and the volatility is 40% per annum. With our

usual notation, this means that S = 50, X = 50, r = 0.10, = 0.40, and T = 0.4167.

Suppose that we break the life of the option into five intervals of length one

month (= 0.0833 year) for the purposes of constructing a binomial tree. Then =

0.0833 and using the formulas,

The top value in the tree diagram above shows the stock price at the node while

the lower one shows the value of the option at the node. The probability of an

up movement is always 0.5076; the probability of a down movement is always

0.4924.

Here the stock price at the jth node (j = 0, 1, ..., i) at time is calculated as

. Also the option prices at the penultimate nodes are calculated from the

option prices at the first final nodes. First we assume no exercise of the

option at the nodes. This means that the option price is calculated as the

present value of expected option price in time . For example at node E the

option price is calculated as while at node A it is calculated as

Then it is possible to check if early exercise of the option is

worthwhile. At node E, the option has a value of zero as both the stock price

and strike price are $50. Thus it is best to wait and the correct value at node

E is $2.66. Yet the option should be exercised at node A if it is reached

because the option would be worth $50.00 - $39.69 or $10.31, which is obviously

higher than $9.90. Options in earlier nodes are calculated in a similar way.

As we keep on calculating backward, we find the value of the option at the

initial node to be $4.48, which is the numerical estimate for the option's

current value. However in practice, a smaller value of would be used by which

the true value of the option would be $4.29. (Hull, p347, 3rd Ed)

The second technique that is commonly used is the so-called Finite Difference

Methods. These methods value a derivative by solving the differential equation

that the derivative satisfies. The differential equation is converted into a

set of difference equations and the difference equations are solved repeatedly.

For instance, in order to value an American put option on a non-dividend-paying

stock by using this method, the differential equation that the option must

satisfy is

The Finite Difference Methods are similar to tree approaches in

that the computations work back from the end of the life of the derivative to

the beginning. There are two different methods involved; one is called the

Explicit Finite Difference Method and the other is the Implicit Finite

Difference Method. The former is functionally the same as using a trinomial

tree. The latter is more complicated but has the advantage that the user does

not have to take any special precautions to ensure convergence. The main

drawback of these methods is they cannot easily be used in situations where the

pay-off from a derivative depends on the past history of the underlying variable.

Finally there is also an alternative to the numerical procedures which is known

as a number of analytic approximations to the valuation of American options.

The best known of these is a quadratic approximation approach proposed by

MacMillan and then extended by Barone-Adesi and Whalley. This method involves

estimating the difference, v, between the European option price and the American

option price since v must satisfy the differential equation for both. They then

show that when an approximation is made, the differential equation can be solved

using standard methods.

The techniques mentioned in this paper are those commonly used in practise.

Although they are not perfect, they are still considered good enough for

practical purposes. So far no one has managed to create a direct analytical

valuation method for valuing American put options.