Morality and Gay Rights Discourse Essay

Morality and Gay Rights Discourse Essay

Length: 2631 words (7.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Morality and Gay Rights Discourse


When Aristotle discussed the material premises of enthymemes as being important in rhetoric, he was prescient of the kind of appeals that would be tendered by opponents in the discourse over gay rights issues long after his time. Smith and Windes express the nature of this conflict accurately when they write, “symbols expressing fundamental cultural values are invoked by all sides” (1997: 28). Similarly, Sarah S. Brown describes the participants in a “struggle to stake out symbolic positions of good and to frame their side in terms of morally powerful conceptions of right and wrong” (2000: 458). Fascinatingly, she suggests, “even people with deeply conflicting opinions appeal to the same moral concepts for the force of their arguments” (458). In fact, these same moral concepts are ubiquitous to all discourse and to life. They penetrate the social order at the most fundamental level. They are not static, however, and their malleability gives rise to a constantly shifting landscape of debate wherein, as Smith and Windes (1997) assert, the adversaries literally have so much impact as to drive the process of self-definition for one another.

Related to that process is the way in which the landscape itself is defined, which Haider-Markel and Meier see as consequential in terms of “what resources are important and [what] advantages some coalitions [in the struggle] have over others” (1996: 346). (See also: Kintz, 1998; Smith and Windes, 1997). Particularly, they demonstrate that models of discourse which conceptualize gay issues in terms of morality (or culture) as opposed to politics or civil rights offer a rhetorical upper hand to proponents of anti-gay arguments. It is the objectiv...


... middle of paper ...


...vation in Gay Rights/Special Rights.” In: Kintz, Linda and Lesage, Julia. 1998. Media , Culture, and the Religious Right. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Patten, Steve. “Preston Manning’s Populism: constructing the common sense of the common people.” Studies in Political Economy, Vol.50 (Summer, 1996): 95

Schulze, Laurie and Guilfoyle, Frances. “Facts Don’t Hate; They Just Are.” In: Kintz, Linda and Lesage, Julia. 1998. Media , Culture, and the Religious Right. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Smith, Ralph R. and Windes, Russel R. “The Progay and Antigay Issue Culture: Interpretation, Influence, and Dissent.” Quarterly Journal of Speech, Vol. 83 (1997): 28-48

Terry, Jennifer. “Unatural Acts In Nature: The Scientific Fascination with Queer Animals.” QLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies, Vol.6.2 (2000): 151-193

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Gay Rights in Ireland

- The Republic of Ireland has a complicated relationship with contemporary human rights laws that many western nation-states have been setting the precedent for, for quite some time. The Republic of Ireland prides itself on its strong Catholic roots, and indeed the adherence to what is essentially Catholic law. Ireland has a unique history that has seemed to act as both an enabler and an explanation as to why for a ‘western country’ it has been able to remain “about twenty years behind the west” (Hug 2001:26)....   [tags: Gay Rights Essays]

Powerful Essays
2911 words (8.3 pages)

Human Rights And The Rights Discourse Essay

- ... Subsequent attempts to conceptualise human rights have provided different approaches and interpretations, for example criticising religious nature of human rights during the period of Enlightenment (Langlois, 2012: 342-343). This suggests two important points. Firstly, the ideational development of current international human rights has taken place largely within the Western intellectual boundaries. Secondly, the construction of idea of rights is substantially linked to socio-political contexts, rather than to the theoretical aspect alone (Langlois, 2012: 343)....   [tags: Human rights]

Powerful Essays
1089 words (3.1 pages)

The Fight for Gay Rights Essay

- The fight for gay rights has always been going on in America. The purpose of the gay rights movement was to earn equal rights for homosexual couples which were denied to them because of the belief that it was “wrong”. But in the early 1900’s homosexuals became more outspoken about their right to be equal. In 1951 the first gay rights organization is formed by Harry Hay, who some consider the founder of the Gay Rights Movement. In 1962 Illinois became the first state to decriminalize relations between two men with consent....   [tags: gay rights movement, LGBTQ, homosexual]

Powerful Essays
1139 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Should Gay Rights Be Legal?

- ... In Wendy Fenwick’s article, “Why Russia 's Anti-Gay Backlash Will Backfire”, Wendy mentions, “justification for the…law was that Russia is facing a demographic collapse, what with birth rates low and death rates high” (Fenwick). Vladimir Putin allows these beating to proceed due to Russia’s population issues, or so it has been claimed. This, however, is not a reason to beat citizens to death for his or her homosexual lifestyle. A person can be completely heterosexual and not want kids ergo no more children are born into Russia’s population and the death rates would not be as high if the gay community did not suffer the way that they have been....   [tags: Homosexuality, LGBT, Gay, Sexual orientation]

Powerful Essays
1633 words (4.7 pages)

The Spark That Lit the Gay Rights Movement Essay

- As New York City was waking up on Saturday, June 28, 1969, the New York City police raided the Stonewall Inn, a popular gay bar in Greenwich Village. The raid led to riots and protests that lasted several days. Such police harassment was hardly uncommon at the time, but this particular raid proved to be the last straw. What could have been a quickly forgotten brawl instead became “the beginning of the modern struggle for gay civil rights” (Teal). The Stonewall Riots pushed the gay rights movement to the forefront of hot-button topics in the United States, where it has remained ever since (Teal)....   [tags: gay rights, stonewall riots, same sex couples]

Powerful Essays
1698 words (4.9 pages)

Liberty and Justice for All: The Pursuit for Gay Rights Essay

- Historically defined as the union between a man and women the idea of marriage has been socially ingrained into the minds of Americans leaving any other possibilities of who love can happen between as unacceptable. These strong societal beliefs are far from the truth yet dictate the ability of homosexuals rights to marry one another. Avoiding defining what marriage entails in the constitution, the issue of whether or not gay people have the right to marry has become a state issue. The conservative idea of marriage is changing as society is undergoing a transformation in its beliefs to a more liberal stance....   [tags: gay rights, same sex]

Powerful Essays
1251 words (3.6 pages)

The Rights Of Uganda Gay Rights Essay examples

- ... In the beginning it was just him, now he was a group of individuals who travel with him. Which is the American family Association. Since he was so well known, he got sent to Uganda to preach the hate over the gay community (“Scott Lively” 3). He was sent to Uganda in March of 2009, which he held a conference at an anti- LBGT movement. They wanted to expose what being homosexual was all about (“Scott Lively” 3). He told about stories that would take offense to gay rights (“Scott Lively”3). Many people attend the conference in Uganda....   [tags: Homosexuality, LGBT, Gay, Sexual orientation]

Powerful Essays
1906 words (5.4 pages)

Gay Rights And Lgbt Rights Essay example

- This was seen a major victory for gay rights in Canada, and championed by many activists. While this was not the end of the fight, many in the community saw this as the last great fight for rights, but it begged the questions who actually wanted these rights. Not everyone in the gay community wanted to be a part of the so-called “nuclear family” and criticized the idea that they should have to fit within traditional heterosexual norms in order to be considered legitimate (Warner 2002, 218). This leads to a bigger question about the exact nature of rights LGBT activists were fighting for throughout history, and how that affected how they fought....   [tags: Homosexuality, LGBT, Gay Liberation, Bisexuality]

Powerful Essays
1204 words (3.4 pages)

Lawrence v. Texas and the History of Gay Rights Essay

- Gay rights have always faced an uphill battle in a country like America, one founded with Puritanical ideals rife with sexual repression. Viewed as sexual deviants and detrimental to society, the LGBT community has fought discrimination long before the acronym for the gay community ever even existed. The public fight for sexual equality goes all the way back to the 1920s, when “The Society for Human Rights in Chicago [became] the country's earliest known gay rights organization” (Infoplease 2013)....   [tags: LGBT rights, gay rights, alternative lifestyle]

Powerful Essays
2561 words (7.3 pages)

Morality : Morality And Morality Essay

- ... The benefit of the moral theory is a better world for people to live in, though this is an oversimplification, the root of the morality theory is altruism. [Posner] Moravcisk’s theory of Republican Liberalism can be equated with morality in order for it to fit within the sphere of the three main theories. Moravcisk’s Republican Liberalism theory has both domestic and international components. The domestic side of his argument is that states (this is places a particular emphasis on the current leader) engage in international law to constrain future governments....   [tags: Law, Morality, Human rights, Ethics]

Powerful Essays
1089 words (3.1 pages)