Essay on A Critique of Thomas B. Stoddard’s Gay Marriages: Make Them Legal

Essay on A Critique of Thomas B. Stoddard’s Gay Marriages: Make Them Legal

Length: 1110 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Thomas B. Stoddard’s “Gay Marriages: Make Them Legal” is a successfully written argument with some minor flaws in technique. Stoddard uses this article to present his major claim, or central thesis, on the reasons gay marriage should be legalized. He presents his argument using minor claims. In a lecture on February 2, 2005, James McFadden stated a minor claim is the secondary claim in an argument. Stoddard uses minor claims in his discussion of homosexual people being denied their rights by the government and by others who discriminate against them. He also discusses how love and the desire for commitment play a big part in the argument for and against gay marriage.

Stoddard begins his argument successfully with pathos, or emotional appeal, to attain the reader’s empathy for those who have been deprived of a loved one. The story tells of a woman named Karen Thompson, who was basically married, but not legally, to her female partner; when Thompson’s partner was in a critical car accident, her partner’s parents completely cut Thompson off from all contact with their daughter. Had the two women been married, they would not have had to deal with such heart-throbbing pain. This example is effective on presenting how marriage “can be the key to survival, emotional and financial” (Stoddard, 1988, p. 551). Making the readers attentive to their feelings captures their attention to the issue of gay marriage and supports his first minor claim.

He continues to support the main claim by showing his knowledge of married couples’ legal rights. He explains that homosexual couples that are not allowed to marry are denied tax breaks, group insurance, and pension programs (Stoddard, 1988, p. 551). These are important grounds,...

... middle of paper ...

... wish, but may not be allowed to marry them. To the government, marriage is a legal contract and love is an emotional connection.

Stoddard uses many successful techniques to support his major claim that gay marriage should be made legal. He misuses a few techniques, but overall his paper was a success. He keeps his argument strong through emotional appeal, strong evidence, use of authority, and great warrants.


Barnet S., & Bedau H. (Eds.). (2005). Current issues and enduring questions: a guide to
critical thinking and argument, with readings. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s.

Stoddard, T. B. (2005). Gay marriages: should they be legalized? In Barnet
S., & Bedau H. (Eds.) Current issues and enduring questions: a guide to critical thinking and argument, with readings. (pp.551-552). Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Should Gay Marriages Be Legalized Essay

- Should Gay Marriages be Legalized. Homosexuality is a hot topic in the world today. We see it on the news, hear it on the radio and even read about it in the newspaper. I believe there will always be homosexuals as long as people live. For years society has looked down upon and condemned gays and lesbians. Even the Constitution of the United States forbids certain rights to homosexuals. For years homosexuals were not allowed to serve in the military unless they hid their sexuality. As I got older and came in contact with homosexuals and have friends and family members that are open about their sexuality, I sometimes question my beliefs, because most of the homosexuals I know personally have...   [tags: Homosexuality, Marriages, Society, Legal]

Strong Essays
1194 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about Same Sex Marriages Should Be Legal

- ... In addition, a violation of equality is evident when the same-sex couples are denied the right to marry. A marriage is a collective right that cannot be exercised by a single individual in the same way as individual rights like freedom of speech (William 590). Therefore, marriage is a right that belongs to couples as the social unit. In this sense, regardless of the sex of the persons involved in a particular wedding, no one should be denied to enjoy this right. Consequently, same-sex couples will have the freedom to exercise their right to marry and increase their happiness that is associated with marriages (William 590)....   [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, Civil union, Rights]

Strong Essays
1383 words (4 pages)

Pro Same Sex Marriages Essay

- Imagine not being able to marry the person you want to spend the rest of your life with because society doesn’t believe in who you are or who you choose to be with. Just think, of the scenario where you loved a person with all your heart, all your mind, all your soul, but society doesn’t believe that who you love, is “right”. Gay rights should be legalized for numerous reasons but the three most debated over is it will decrease the amount suicide rates of gay teens, its biological, and everyone should be treated equally no matter who they like and who they want to love. To being with, gay rights should be legalized because it will decrease the amount of suicide rates of gay teens and even a...   [tags: legal issues, same sex marriages]

Strong Essays
1059 words (3 pages)

Should Gay Marriage Be Legal? Essay

- Should Gay Marriage Be Legal. Macklamore and Ryan Lewis’s music supports a lot of different things. They rap about lots of things. They could always stick to the status quote and rap about money, girls and fame but instead they choose to write their music about topics that actually matter to Americans. Macklamore, and Ryan Lewis’s music has up bringing beats about human rights and wanting to see people equal. Although he sees every human being as being equal, his mission through his writing and singing is to have people change their point of view and to have the government change their laws to allow two people of the same-sex, two women, or two men to get married....   [tags: same-sex-marriages, democrats]

Strong Essays
1954 words (5.6 pages)

Essay about Homosexual Marriages: Two Sides of the Story

- The topic of homosexual marriages, or the marrying of two people of the same sex, is rather disputed among the majority of people in today’s society. Only small amounts of the population have opinions that are strongly favoring one side of the debate. For most of society who are the middle-of-the-road citizens, it is a tough call to make one way or the other. The main topics that are disputed are raising children in a same-sex household, the capacity of churches to allow such a marriage, and the integrity of a marriage as a legal document....   [tags: Homosexual Marriages, marriage, argumentative, per]

Strong Essays
811 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Arranged Marriages in India, Japan and the Elizabethan Era

- Arranges marriages have had a successful yet oppressive impact on the World’s society since the Elizabethan Era. They have been most commonly found in the eastern cultures such as India and Japan. In the western culture it used to be extremely popular during the Elizabethan Era. As though it seems today that a marriage is to seal the love one has for another, having an arranged marriage is as if sealing a contract with your parents. Arranged marriages influence the societies that use them by providing wealth, money, and power to the couples and their families even if the marriage is unjust....   [tags: Arranged Marriages Essays]

Strong Essays
1403 words (4 pages)

Critique On Against Gay Marriage Essay

- Critique on Against Gay Marriage Is marriage strictly between male and female, or should it also be open for homosexuals. William Bennett, a well known politician believes in the traditional marriage, being between a male and female. His thesis reads “We are engaged in a debate which, in a less confused time, would be considered pointless and even oxymoronic: the question of the same-sex marriage” (409). Not only is this statement bias, but other elements of his work held problems. The way his case was defended was ineffective to his case....   [tags: Homosexuality, Same-sex marriage, Marriage]

Strong Essays
1068 words (3.1 pages)

Essay Should Same Sex Marriages Be Allowed?

- Should Same Sex Marriages Be Allowed. An ongoing debate: Should gay and lesbian couples be allowed to legally marry. In the opposing articles from Newsweek (June 3, 1996), Andrew Sullivan defends the rights of gay marriage in “Let Gays Marry” and William Bennett expresses the opposite view in “Leave Marriage Alone.” Sullivan is one of the editors for The New Republic and has also authored a book entitled Virtually Normal: An Argument about Homosexuality. [Gruber 25] Bennett is best known as the editor of The Book of Virtues and is also the co-director of Empower America....   [tags: Marriages Homosexuality Essays]

Strong Essays
1165 words (3.3 pages)

Same Sex Marriages Should be Legal Essay example

- Same Sex Marriages Should be Legal   Flowers, candles, and music are all part of a wedding. As the organist plays "Here Comes the Bride," I notice this is where the similarities end. The bride, who is a woman, is marrying a groom, who is also a woman. Single-sex marriages are only allowed in a few states. However, single-sex marriages should become legal so that couples could enjoy the advantages of marriage. Legalizing single-sex marriage would create more family units and create more tolerance from society, allowing single-sex couples a legal way of expressing their love to each other....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics Gay Lesbian]

Strong Essays
835 words (2.4 pages)

Gay Marriages Essay

- In today’s society there are many factors that contribute to the ever-continuing social inequality of people through out Canada. It is no wonder as to why there are so many stereotypes of what is socially ‘acceptable’ and what isn’t when the media is forcing these ‘norms’ into our minds. What is ‘ideal’ with in today’s expectations isn’t always attainable due the fact that everyone is different. One of the most controversial topics being discussed today is view on same sex marriage. This notorious topic is nothing new, however, there is an ongoing debate as to whether or not make it legal for couples of the same sex to engage in a marital status....   [tags: Same Sex Marriage Essays]

Strong Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)