Jurors on a Death Penalty Case Essay

Jurors on a Death Penalty Case Essay

Length: 956 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

One of the most intense group task experiences in the United States is that of serving on the jury of a death penalty case. This forces a group of complete strangers to come together and determine the fate of another’s human beings life. The court case of the State of Ohio v Mark Ducic, was of no exception. Ducic a 47 year old drug addict white male, was accused of committing a double homicide. In accordance with Ohio state law, murdering more than one individual is considered a mass murder and therefore the accused is subject to the possibility of the death penalty. Ducic’s victims included Barbara Davis, his domestic partner and drug addict, as well as a drug user that Ducic was an acquaintance with. The death of Davis was at first believed to be due to an overdose, but police informants identified Ducic’s voice on a recording claiming that he killed her. The other victim, the drug addict, was thought to be eliminated by Ducic for fear that he would inform the police that he killed Davis. Investigators believed that Ducic gave both victims a deathly amount of drugs that would make it appear as though they both simply overdosed. Ducic was found guilty on both occasions, yet a second trial in regards to his sentencing had to occur and another hearing had to be conducted on whether or not to remove the death penalty.
As one of the seven jury deliberations documented and recorded in the ABC News television series In the Jury Room the discussions of the jurors were able to be seen throughout the United States. A transcript was also created by ABC News for the public as well. The emotions and interactions of the jurors were now capable of being portrayed to anyone interested in the interworkings of jury deliberations. The first task,...


... middle of paper ...


...ive years to thirty years is nothing he could do with the world because the way it’s changing now. He will be a stranger waling out of here. Who is going to listen to an old man? Now he going to do good. He can write a book while he in there, you know. And if you wondered about coming back here, he doesn’t even want to. Don’t anybody want to be here twenty- five years not the way things are going now.
Juror 12: I disagree because a lot of people do go to the schools that are older, and educate people that don’t have no clue who they are. Be it grandmothers, whatever, and I want to just…
Juror 8: You are speculating that” (State of Ohio v. Mark Ducic, ln 1666-1679).



Works Cited

Aggravated murder: death penalty sentencing phase deliberations state of Ohio v. mark Ducic
Bicks, M. (Director). (2004). In the jury room: The State of Ohio vs Mark Ducic: ABC News.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Jurors and Cases in Court Essay

- The reason for these reactions is due to the fact that jurors are all influenced by different decision making abilities. These abilities can be shaped by varying emotional reactions to case information, jurors intelligence, their abilities to retain certain information, and of course their own personal and cultural views. As a result, jurors establish different perceptions and opinions despite all the jurors being given the same information. The procedure of applying a juror’s perception of certain views on life and how those views apply to the facts and information being presented to them in the case are the main forces behind each juror’s individual conclusions on the case....   [tags: Influencing Decisions, Court, Cases, Jurors]

Better Essays
988 words (2.8 pages)

The Death Penalty Essay

- The Death Penalty; What Tennessee Should Do About It. The U.S. Constitution’s Eighth Amendment says that the death sentenced prisoners should not face execution after the death penalty and should not be treated any less then the eighteenth century prisoners. So why is capital punishment still legal in the state of Tennessee. It is true that Tennessee does not keep up with much of the data for the cost record, but the records they do have shown how expensive it is to prosecute someone....   [tags: american correctional policy]

Better Essays
2096 words (6 pages)

The Anti Death Penalty Movement Essay

- ... A study published by Circuit Judge Arthur L. Alarcon and Paula Mitchell, “Cost of Capital Punishment in California: Will Voters Choose Reform This November: The Case of Los Angeles County.” published in “The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology,” found that in California “Jury selection could take as much as a month longer in death penalty trials and cost roughly $200,000.00 more than in other murder trials.” (Alarcon) For the defense side jury selection must consider the need for jurors who can in some way empathize with someone facing death as well as understand the true meaning of beyond a reasonable doubt....   [tags: Capital punishment]

Better Essays
1805 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on The Death Penalty Is A Man

- ... There are forty-one capital offenses in the United States. The process to convict and sentence someone to a death penalty is lengthy and meticulous. Rarely do law enforcement come upon such a crime in progress. After an person is arrested they go through the same thorough process as any other alleged criminal. However, during pretrial the prosecution will say whether or not they are seeking a death penalty conviction. Once a trial is set in place the jury selection begins. Before the case Jurors are heavily briefed....   [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Prison, Murder]

Better Essays
1314 words (3.8 pages)

The Death Penalty Is Not Legal Essay

- ... Deterrence One of the most common arguments in support of the death penalty is the claim that it functions as a deterrent to crime. However, severity of punishment is one of the least effective methods of deterrence and recent research has shown that the death penalty’s deterrence effects are grossly over exaggerated. A large number of studies previously claimed that the death penalty acted as a deterrent and subsequently decreased murder rates. However, a 2012 report, which reviewed over 30 years of research on the topic, came to the conclusion that these studies were fundamentally flawed....   [tags: Capital punishment, Murder, Death row, Prison]

Better Essays
1157 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on There's No Evidence The Death Penalty Deters Crime

- Capital punishment is very popular with the majority of Americans. Maybe, in part, because it feeds the inborn human need to feel revenge. The death penalty is also very popular politically and provides a way for politicians to show that they are fighting crime. Thirty-eight states have death penalty statutes and several other states are considering legislation to enact it. Yet, is capital punishment really effective and does it deter crime. I believe that it does not. Polls show that most Americans support the death penalty and see it as a deterrent to crime....   [tags: Capital Punishment Doesn't Deter Crime]

Better Essays
1753 words (5 pages)

Capital Punishment: A Negative Way to Deter Crime Essay

- An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, a hand for a hand, and a foot for a foot is a well known phrase that means when someone commits a wrongdoing against another person they must be punished the same way. But how far can this statement go, should the government have rights to kill someone if a person kills another. Or does anyone have the right to sentence a person to the death penalty even if they stole grapes or killed a chicken. The death penalty may limit crime, but it is not a positive form of punishment due to the financial burdens on the government, killings of the innocent, and moral and ethical issues....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Better Essays
2310 words (6.6 pages)

Death Penalty Should Be Abolished Essay

- The justice system in many countries allow the law to have death penalty. If the death penalty should be abolished or not has been an argument between a lot of people. Some people don’t agree that death penalty should be abolished because they believe that the delinquent will try to escape from prison and commit more crimes, but in reality death penalty should definitely be abolished. Sure death penalty can prevent the prisoners from committing more crimes such as murder, but we are punishing them from killing someone else, yet we are doing the exact thing....   [tags: Capital punishment]

Better Essays
1036 words (3 pages)

Essay on For the Death Penalty

- For the Death Penalty Are we effectively punishing our most vile and baneful criminals. I believe some improvement to be necessary; the death penalty should be legalized in all states. The United States should utilize the capital punishment because it is economical and has deterring and incapacitating effects. While life with no parole sentencing is a valid alternative, the death penalty is in public favor, ruled as constitutional, is humane, and allows convicts many opportunities to appeal. While many people will claim that too many inmates are executed, the national death row currently has a population of 3726 criminals, consisting of 3669 men and 57 women, and only 712 convicts have bee...   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
960 words (2.7 pages)

Race and the Death Penalty Essays

- The death penalty is one of the most controversial issues on American soil. Blacks are more likely to face the death penalty than whites in the commission of identical crimes(CNN, 2014). The history of capital punishment dates back to the days before Christ. The Old Testament adage 'an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth,' has survived throughout the ages despite the New Testament's rendition of 'thou shall not kill'. Today's American victims endure a more demure of style of cruel and unusual punishment; death by lethal injection has replaced the barbaric traditions of the past....   [tags: Capital Punishment Race African-Americans]

Better Essays
2117 words (6 pages)