The Constitutional Right Of Gay Marriage Essay

The Constitutional Right Of Gay Marriage Essay

Length: 938 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The constitutional right of gay marriage is a hot topic for debate in the United States. Currently, 37 states have legal gay marriage, while 13 states have banned gay marriage. The two essays, "What’s Wrong with Gay Marriage?" by Katha Pollitt and "Gay "Marriage": Societal Suicide" by Charles Colson provide a compare and contrast view of why gay marriage should be legal or not. Pollitt argues that gay marriage is a constitutional human right and that it should be legal, while Colson believes that gay marriage is sacrilegious act that should not be legal in the United States and that “it provides a backdrop for broken families and increases crime rates” (Colson, pg535). Both authors provide examples to support their thesis. Katha Pollitt provides more relevant data to support that gay marriage is a constitutional right and should be enacted as law in our entire country, she has a true libertarian mindset.
"In her Nation column, Pollitt regularly takes on political topics from an unabashedly liberal perspective" (Pollitt, pg. 529). Pollitt argues in her essay, "What 's Wrong with Gay Marriage?" with some of the most well-known arguments that the anti-gay marriage movement has presented. The format she uses is quite unique for breaking down her rebuttals to the theories that gay marriage should not be legal. She uses an outline of presenting the theory and then presenting her theory to discredit it. The first and most widely known theory for not supporting gay marriage would be the procreation theory. Pollitt argues that "there is something creepily authoritarian and insulting about reducing marriage to procreation, as if intimacy mattered less than biological fitness. It 's not the view that anyone outside a right-wing think tank...


... middle of paper ...


...tedly agree with their stance on the constitutional right of gay marriage. Katha Pollitt believes that "gay marriage is not about sex, it 's about separation of church and state"(Pollitt, pg. 531), which truly embodies the ideals of a true libertarian mindset. On the other hand, Colson believes that "marriage is not a private institution designed solely for the individual gratification of its participants"(Colson, pg. 536) and that if the US "fails to enact a Federal Marriage Amendment, we can expect, not just more family breakdown, but also more criminals behind bars and more chaos in the streets"(Colson, pg. 536). Each author is entitled to their person opinion on the legality of gay marriage. Of course, from a libertarian perspective, that is their very personal human right, even before governments created constitutional rights that protect freedom of speech.




Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Why Gay Marriage Is Constitutional Essay

- Traditional wedding vows state, “I, (name), take you (name), to be my (wife/husband), to have and to hold from this day forward, for better or for worse, for richer, for poorer, in sickness and in health, to love and to cherish; from this day forward until death do us part”(Callaway). Marriage is defined as two people bond together legally under the protection of laws. Couples are able to express and establish their life long relationships officially, publicly, and permanently. Due to the fact that homosexual relationships are increasingly more accepted by the public, gay marriage has become one of the most controversial topics throughout the US....   [tags: 9th Amendment, Civil Rights]

Better Essays
2444 words (7 pages)

Essay on Traditional and Gay Marriage

- Although marriage is recognized legally, religiously, and socially by various groups of people, it has a central meaning. The widely accepted definition of marriage is the lifelong commitment of a man and a woman to each other, sanctioned by God and State, in order to bear children and obtain a companion. Traditional arguments state that the right to marry belongs to heterosexuals. Today, however, same-sex marriage has become a challenge to that theory and is positively redefining the way society views marriage....   [tags: gay rights, homosexual couples]

Better Essays
850 words (2.4 pages)

Gay Marriage Should Be Legal Essay

- ... Department of Public Health. Shortly after the Supreme Court’s ruling, the mayor of San Francisco, Gavin Newsom, authorized city clerks to grant marriage licenses to same sex couples. The city of San Francisco then went on to sue the State of California “to challenge the ban on same sex marriages on constitutional grounds” (277). The struggle for homosexuals to achieve marriage licenses illustrates a “disadvantage group that is being denied the fundamental rights to marry, which is taken granted by hetersexuals” (Hsu 290.) Legalizing gay marriage will result to an economic boom, creating more revenue to support the economy....   [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, Homosexuality]

Better Essays
1202 words (3.4 pages)

Gay Marriage Is a Human Rights Issue Essay

- The divorce rate among homosexual couples is nearly half the divorce rate of heterosexual couples, in states where homosexual marriage is already legal. This statistic makes it evident that homosexual marriage is as successful as heterosexual marriage. However, out of 49 states with laws regarding gay marriage, only 13 legally recognize the union of two same sex people. Some of the reasoning for this is because some people believe that homosexuality is against their religion and thus, homosexual couples should not have equal rights....   [tags: homosexual marriage, gay couples, equal protection]

Better Essays
1087 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on We Must Legalize Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Transsexual Marriage

- In the state of Oklahoma, there are political, social, and legal barriers that restrict gay marriage within the state boundaries. In pursuing the “American Dream”, gay marriage is a natural right given to every human living his or her life in this country. Natural, inalienable, rights provide a way of life in which eternal love is an example of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. I believe that Gays, Lesbians, Bisexuals, and Transsexuals should be granted the right to marry. As passive as the James Madison: Checks and Balances system has become, the federalist relationship became significantly close between national and state governments on the subject of gay marriage....   [tags: Legal Issues, Gay Marriage]

Better Essays
1231 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about Gay Marriage Should Be Legal

- The issue at hand with the Supreme Court was whether the four states remaining (Tennessee, Ohio, Michigan and Kentucky) same-sex marriage bans violated the 14th amendment of the U.S. Constitution. The 6th Circuit Court of Appeals found that those bans were constitutional. In 2003 the state of Massachusetts high court to find “to find a right to marriage equality in a state constitution” (Emily Bazelon, 2015). It is up to the higher courts of our United States to decide whether the federal Constitution will require all states to either license same-sex unions or to acknowledge those unions if they were performed somewhere else....   [tags: Same-sex marriage, Marriage]

Better Essays
777 words (2.2 pages)

Legalize Gay Marriage Essays

- Same-Sex Marriage Should Be Legalized Just about everyone has an opinion on legally allowing same-sex couples to marry. The arguments range from personal beliefs to what marriage is said to be in the Bible. Why should a couple be forbidden from showing each other along with family and friends that they are fully committed to each other. What place is it for the government to say that said couple is not allowed to commit to the one who truly makes you happy. Why should these people who are willing to be together for better or worse, in sickness and health, for richer or poorer not get the respect, consideration, and benefits that any opposite sex couple are granted....   [tags: Gay Rights, argumentative, persuasive]

Better Essays
1503 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on The Legalization Of Gay Marriage

- ... We all have the choice to pick who we marry, but people argue that marriage should only be between a male and female. We fought the British because we were denied our basic, unalienable rights, but now it seems as if we fought for nothing because we are the ones denying those rights. This is a free country, and we should all have the same rights as any human being. We all have our own rights and we must be able to do what makes us happy. We all deserve the same rights as any human being. We weren’t born to be perfect, and if they choose to get married with someone of the same sex, let them....   [tags: Homosexuality, Same-sex marriage, Marriage]

Better Essays
1260 words (3.6 pages)

Gay Marriage: A Modern Soddom and Gomorra Essay

-         Gay parenting and marriage has become publicly accepted by some and rejected by others. Many have come to believe this topic to be immoral and impossible. Society has also realized that the average family has developed into many different forms in the last few years. Gay families have developed and are perceived today that raising kids without both a Mom and Dad, deprives the child from being introduced to both worlds. The approach to this debated topic will be to analyze and to defend the “cons” of gay parenting and marriage....   [tags: Against Gay Marriage, Argumentative Essay]

Better Essays
1804 words (5.2 pages)

Gay Marriage Essay

- Gay Marriage There seem to be Specific time in history where certain issues define the culture tension in a society. They become representative of large worldview and clearly emphasize the battle between divergent moral and spiritual perspectives. Homosexual marriage in the United States is one of these issues. In the past five years, there have been various threats and debates about the possibility of legalizing homosexual union. The issue took centre stage in February largely. The U.S Senate quashes a proposed constitutional amendment to ban gays from marrying....   [tags: Same-Sex Marriage Essays]

Better Essays
1228 words (3.5 pages)